Two Carmen styles, one key difference
The Carmen bralette and the Sheer bra - Carmen 1 look like the same design, and in most respects they are. Both are sheer embroidered bras with red and black floral embroidery over translucent tulle, soft red picot-edge elastics, and a red silk band. The practical difference is in the band elastic: the Carmen 1 sample has a slightly stretchier band than the regular Carmen, which changes who each one fits.
If you are deciding between them, focus on two things: how much coverage and lining you want, and which band size will actually stay put. The embroidery and tulle are sheer in both, so neither is a full-coverage padded bra. The Carmen 1 is a sample-sale piece in size S only, while the Carmen bralette comes in XS through XL.
Lining and coverage: what each style actually gives you
Neither bra is described as having molded cups or padding. The coverage comes from the embroidered tulle and the way the band and straps hold it against the body.
- Carmen bralette: Sheer red and black floral embroidery over translucent tulle, with scalloped edges along the neckline and a ruched crimson silk band at the base. The tulle is described as soft and translucent, so expect a sheer look rather than opaque coverage. Fully adjustable satin elastic straps and a black enameled metal hook closure with 2 loop options let you fine-tune the fit.
- Sheer bra - Carmen 1: The same red bespoke embroidery, lined in sheer tulle, with soft red picot-edge elastics and beige elastic at the front edge. The lining here is sheer tulle, not an opaque layer, so coverage remains sheer. The band elastic is slightly stretchier than the regular Carmen, which affects fit more than coverage.
Fit evidence for the Carmen bralette
- Carmen bralette: Available in sizes XS, S, M, L and XL. A size range gives you room to match your band and bust rather than settling for a single sample size.

Carmen bralette - Carmen bralette: Fully adjustable satin elastic straps and a back hook closure with 2 loop options. These adjustments let you tune strap tension and band fit, which matters in a sheer style where the band does much of the supporting.
- Carmen bralette: Models wear sizes M - 34B, M - 34C, and L - 36C. These are the only model fit references supplied; use them as a rough guide, not a substitute for your own measurements.
Fit evidence for the Sheer bra - Carmen 1
- Sheer bra - Carmen 1: Sample sale, size S only. The band elastic is slightly stretchier than the regular Carmen, so it fits a 32/34 band instead of a 32 band, or a 32 with a looser fit. If you are a true 32 band and want a firm hold, the Carmen 1 may feel loose; if you are between 32 and 34, it could be the more comfortable choice.

Sheer bra - Carmen 1 - Sheer bra - Carmen 1: Condition: new and never worn merchandise, at 35% off the comparison price. The sample-sale price reflects a single size and the stretchier band, not wear or damage.
- Sheer bra - Carmen 1: Features red bespoke embroidery lined in sheer tulle, with soft red picot-edge elastics, beige elastic at the front edge, and a red silk bra band. Made in the UK. The construction matches the Carmen look, so your decision comes down to fit and availability rather than a different aesthetic.
How to choose between them
Start with your band size. If you normally wear a 32 band and prefer a firm, secure feel, the regular Carmen bralette in your size is the more predictable choice, and you can adjust the straps and hook to refine it. If you wear a 34 band, or a 32 and prefer a softer, looser band, the Carmen 1 in size S is designed for that fit.
Next, consider how much choice you want. The Carmen bralette comes in five sizes, so you can match your usual size. The Carmen 1 is a single sample size, which makes it a good option only if its band range matches you. Neither style is lined with an opaque fabric, so if you want fuller coverage, look for a different bralette style rather than expecting these to act as a padded bra.
Finally, think about care. Both are hand wash and lay flat to dry. The Carmen 1's sample-sale status does not change that; treat the embroidery and tulle gently to keep the sheer look intact.
What the evidence does not tell you
The supplied records do not include a detailed size chart with bust measurements, nor do they state cup sizing for either style. The model sizes for the Carmen bralette (M - 34B, M - 34C, L - 36C) are the only fit references given, and the Carmen 1 has no model fit notes. If you are outside those references, use your own band and bust measurements and treat the size range as a starting point, not a guarantee.
The records also do not confirm whether either style has removable pads, underwires, or adjustable back bands beyond the hook options listed. If those features matter to you, check the product page details before ordering rather than assuming.



